BJ's Wholesale Club heads into its June 18 Q1 results carrying the weight of two consecutive double-digit post-earnings drops — and a Street that has quietly lost conviction.
The most striking feature of this setup is the earnings history. The last two prints each sent BJ's stock down roughly 9–10% on the day, with five-day losses of similar magnitude. That kind of consistent negative reaction pattern sets an unusually high bar for the company to clear. The stock has done little to rebuild confidence in the interim, down about 1% over the past month to $91.04, despite a modest 2% recovery this week. Short interest, at nearly 6% of the free float with roughly 7.9 million shares short, is meaningful but has been range-bound — up about 2% on the week yet only 1% higher over the past month. The borrow market offers no amplifying signal: availability is extremely loose at over 900% of short interest, and the cost to borrow is barely above 0.5%, eased 7% in the past week. Short sellers are present but not pressing an aggressive trade. Options positioning is equally flat — the put/call ratio of 1.06 sits almost exactly at its 20-day average, with a z-score near zero, a world away from the 52-week high of 1.22 touched in late May.
The bull-bear divide is sharper than the subdued positioning implies. Bulls point to a $20-billion-plus revenue base, recurring membership fee income, and private-label brand momentum as durable structural advantages. Forward EPS estimates for 12 months out show an 83rd-percentile year-on-year increase — the fundamental trajectory still looks constructive on that measure. Bears focus on recent execution: comp growth has disappointed, the P/E at roughly 19x leaves limited room for another miss, and the macro backdrop — tariff pressures, softening consumer spending — weighs on a retailer that sells a high proportion of groceries and general merchandise. Analyst targets have drifted lower. Citi cut its target to $100 in late May while holding a Buy. JPMorgan raised its Neutral target to $98 after trimming it just weeks earlier. Goldman Sachs remains at $123 with a Buy, but that target looks increasingly detached from a stock trading at $91. The consensus is a Hold, with 11 holds and 2 underperforms, and no upgrades in recent months — a posture of wait-and-see rather than confidence.
Institutional ownership adds modest context. Victory Capital added around 1.6 million shares in Q1, and Putnam added nearly 700,000 through April — active managers building positions even as the stock underperformed. But insider activity moves the other way. CEO Bob Eddy sold shares on both April 15 and May 15, totalling roughly $1.5 million across the two months. The Chief Commercial Officer also sold over $1.5 million in April, though that transaction was paired with an award grant. The net insider position over the past 90 days is technically positive in share terms due to award activity, but the pattern of cash sales from the top of the house is hard to read as a vote of confidence ahead of the print.
Thursday's report is ultimately a test of whether BJ's can break a two-quarter streak of double-digit earnings-day losses — and whether the membership model's resilience is enough to offset the deteriorating comp trajectory at a multiple that still demands delivery.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open BJ on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
