KEY heads into its May 14 earnings date with a notable narrative shift: short sellers have pulled back sharply in the past week, while analysts who had gone cautious in early April are now lifting their targets after a solid Q1 print.
The sharpest signal this week is the unwinding of short positions. Short interest fell 10% over the past seven days to 1.96% of free float — a meaningful drop from the ~2.35% level that held steady through most of April. In raw share terms, roughly 2.4 million shares of short exposure came off the books between April 22 and April 24. That drop coincided with the Q1 earnings release on April 16, where the stock moved up 1.1% on the day and added another 1% over the following five sessions. Shorts that built exposure ahead of the quarter have largely retreated. The month-over-month picture is noisier — SI is up 15.6% versus 30 days ago — but that earlier build now looks like an earnings hedge, not a structural bear position.
The lending market tells the same undemanding story. Availability is loose and borrow is cheap at 0.53% annualised, even after a 48% rise in cost-to-borrow over the past week — a move that looks large in percentage terms but is trivial in absolute cost. Availability well exceeds short interest, meaning there is ample room for new shorts if sentiment turns. The ORTEX short score of 29.5 is low and has been drifting lower all month. Options positioning has also eased: the put/call ratio at 0.895 is running slightly below its 20-day average of 0.921, roughly 1.2 standard deviations on the calmer side. There is no meaningful hedging signal here.
The analyst community turned more positive after Q1 results. Evercore ISI raised its target from $24 to $26 while keeping an Outperform. RBC lifted from $22 to $24, also Outperform. Piper Sandler nudged higher to $24. The contrast with early April is sharp: JPMorgan had cut from $24.50 to $22.50 on April 7, and Evercore itself had trimmed from $26 to $24 on April 6 amid macro caution. The post-Q1 revisions reversed most of that. The consensus mean target of $24.92 implies about 15% upside from the current $21.67. The bull case — consecutive quarters of adjusted PPNR growth, 15% year-on-year trust income growth, and improving ROTCE at 13% — is the story the Street is leaning into. The bear case centres on the $59 million quarterly drop in core fee income and a $898 million period-end deposit decline, which point to pockets of revenue pressure that have not gone away. At a price-to-book of 1.27 and a PE of 11.3, the stock is not demanding on either metric.
The ownership picture adds a quietly important subplot. Bank of Nova Scotia — KeyCorp's largest holder at roughly 14.7% of shares — has continued trimming its position, selling approximately $13 million worth of shares in March and another $1.1 million in April. Scotia's steady divestiture has been a persistent technical overhang. Against that, passive flows from Vanguard and BlackRock have been modestly additive, each adding under one million shares in the most recent quarter. The institutional base is broad at 291 holders, so the Scotia selling has not disrupted the register significantly, but it remains worth monitoring as a supply-side factor.
Among peers, KEY's week was roughly in line with the group. RF and CFG each slipped around 1% on the week, while PNC underperformed, falling close to 3%. ZION and USB held fractionally better. The regional banking complex is broadly tracking macro rate sentiment rather than differentiating sharply on fundamentals — KEY's modest 1.7% weekly decline keeps it in the middle of the pack.
With Q2 earnings confirmed for May 14, the next test is whether the loan growth, PPNR, and fee income trends from Q1 hold or soften. The setup heading in: short interest retreating, borrow market relaxed, options not hedging aggressively, and a Street that has just finished revising numbers upward. How deposit levels and investment banking fees trend in the current macro environment will be the question the analyst community is most focused on at the next print.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open KEY on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
