AT&T enters its July 22 earnings date with a notable divergence: short sellers have been aggressively covering while the Street has just turned more cautious, creating an interesting tension between positioning and fundamental narrative.
The most striking move over the past six weeks has been the unwind of bearish positioning. Short interest has fallen 30% from its early-June peak, dropping from around 144 million shares to just under 94 million — now sitting at only 1.3% of the free float. That is a low level by any measure, and the direction of travel is unambiguous. The borrow market reflects the same story: availability is extraordinarily loose, with roughly 82 times more shares available to borrow than are currently shorted. Cost to borrow has stayed near record lows at 0.39%, down 11% on the week. The ORTEX short score has drifted down to 29.7, its lowest in the past 10 days, reinforcing that there is no meaningful short-side pressure building here. Options traders are marginally more guarded than usual — the put/call ratio ticked up to 0.79, about 1.4 standard deviations above its 20-day average of 0.75 — but with the ratio still well below its 52-week high of 0.94, this reads as mild pre-earnings caution rather than a defensive posture.
The Street story is more complicated. The analyst consensus remains a buy, with 11 buy ratings against just 1 sell, and a mean price target of $29.50 — implying roughly 40% upside to Tuesday's close of $21.09. But two significant actions landed this week that complicate that picture. Morgan Stanley, maintaining its Overweight rating, cut its target sharply from $30 to $25 on July 7. The following morning, Wells Fargo initiated with an Underweight and a $18 target — the most bearish call on the Street and one that sits below the current price. Barclays also trimmed its Equal-Weight target from $26 to $24. Three cuts in 48 hours, all pointing in the same direction. The valuation backdrop adds context: AT&T trades at roughly 9.2x earnings and 6.4x EV/EBITDA, both compressing modestly over the past month as the stock has fallen 7%. The analyst recommendation differentiation factor scores in the 95th percentile — meaning the buy skew is historically high relative to peers — which itself can be a flag when the stock is underperforming.
The bull and bear cases are well-established. Bulls point to 74 million postpaid phone customers, a converged-services strategy targeting 12 million bundled customers by 2030, and free cash flow supported by the DirecTV asset sale. Bears focus on declining ARPU in wireless, legacy wireline erosion that could turn EBITDA-negative post-2027, and a payout ratio expected to remain above 100% through at least 2028 — a capital return story that looks stretched at current free cash flow levels. The stock's 7% monthly decline has likely pulled in yield-sensitive buyers, but the week's analyst actions suggest the June selloff may not yet fully reflect the fundamental headwinds.
AT&T's closest peer, VZ, fell 3.4% on the week while AT&T gained 1.9% — a relative outperformance that may owe more to the short covering dynamic than any fundamental re-rating. Looking at recent earnings reactions, the last two prints produced a -2.9% and a +2.8% one-day move respectively — modest, symmetrical reactions that suggest the stock tends not to gap dramatically on results. The July 22 print will therefore be watched less for the number itself and more for management's commentary on ARPU trends, the pace of copper network retirement, and any updated free cash flow guidance that might address the payout ratio concern the bears have just flagged loudest.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open T on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
