POST heads into its August 6 earnings date with short interest at a multi-month high, a fresh analyst target cut, and options positioning that has flipped dramatically more defensive since mid-June.
The most notable development this week came from the Street. Wells Fargo lowered its price target on POST to $98 from $110 on July 8, maintaining an Equal-Weight rating — the third time this analyst has trimmed the target since February. The direction of travel across the coverage universe has been consistently lower: JP Morgan cut to $119 from $133 in April, Barclays followed with a reduction to $119 from $127, and BTIG initiated at Neutral without a target. The three firms that maintain positive ratings — JP Morgan, Barclays, and Mizuho — all carry a consensus mean target around $122, implying roughly 38% upside to the current $88.77. That gap is notable, but targets have been sliding for months. The bull case centres on the 8th Avenue acquisition adding meaningfully to 2026 EBITDA, with synergies still unquantified. Bears point to persistent sales declines across Gravy Train, Nutrish, and discontinued co-manufacturing contracts that pushed FY25 sales growth estimates to -8.5%.
Short positioning tells a story of measured but building conviction against the stock. SI has climbed to 12.7% of the free float — up roughly 6% over the past month — putting it at its highest level in the 30-day window. The ORTEX short score of 66.6 has held in the mid-60s for the past two weeks, off its late-June peak of 67.9 but still firmly elevated. Borrow costs have spiked sharply: cost to borrow more than doubled between July 3 and July 7, jumping to 0.83% from around 0.52%, a 42% weekly move and a 136% rise over the month. That said, absolute borrow costs remain low — 0.83% is not a squeeze-pressure level — and availability is loose at roughly 392% of outstanding short interest, well above the 52-week trough of 198%. Shorts are accumulating, but the lending market is not yet signalling stress.
Options positioning has undergone a sharp structural shift. The put/call ratio has run at roughly 5.3 since late June — a level far above the 20-day average of 3.9 — after sitting below 1.3 through the June 10-18 window. That pivot from call-heavy to aggressively put-heavy happened around June 22, and the ratio has barely moved since. The z-score of 0.68 suggests the current PCR is elevated but not extreme relative to recent variability; the 52-week high is 16.1, so there is room for further defensive skew. The combined picture from short interest and options is one of building caution rather than panic.
The stock has barely responded to any of it. POST is up just 0.6% on the week and down 1.8% over the past month, closing at $88.77. Packaged food peers have been more active: GIS added 2% on the day and nearly 2% on the week, LW gained over 5% on the week, while HSY shed 3.1%. POST's muted performance relative to peers reinforces the factor score picture — EPS momentum over 90 days ranks in the 84th percentile, forward EPS growth estimates rank at the 85th percentile, but the short score ranks in only the 7th percentile of the universe, and momentum has been weakening since May.
Valuation offers some potential anchor. The P/E multiple has contracted roughly 1.2 turns over the past 30 days to around 10.8x, and EV/EBITDA sits near 7.4x — modest multiples for a packaged-food name with active M&A capacity. Chairman Emeritus William Stiritz remains the largest individual holder with a 10.8% stake, though he sold 180,000 shares in December 2025. Director Jeff Zadoks sold a combined ~10,000 shares on July 2, all at around $90.94 — close to current levels, a signal worth noting ahead of the August print.
The August 6 report is the next real catalyst. Recent earnings history shows POST has moved lower on each of the last two prints, declining roughly 1.6% to 2.4% on day one, with five-day returns similarly negative. The combination of building short interest, a defensive options skew, and a steady stream of downward analyst revisions means the setup into that date is worth monitoring closely.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open POST on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
