AutoNation enters its July 23 Q2 earnings print with short sellers quietly backing away and a freshly raised price target from Barclays landing just days before the release.
Short interest has drifted lower this week, falling roughly 0.7% to 6.6% of the free float — about 2.4 million shares. That level is still up 15% from a month ago, meaning bears rebuilt positions through June before trimming into the report. The borrow market tells a relaxed story: cost to borrow is a negligible 0.50%, and availability is exceptionally loose at 1,354% — more than thirteen shares available to lend for every one currently shorted. There is no squeeze pressure here, and no sign the lending pool is tightening. The ORTEX short score has drifted to 50.2 from 52.7 a week ago, a mid-range reading that carries no directional edge either way.
Options positioning has eased from its most defensive extreme, though it remains structurally put-heavy. The put/call ratio is 1.96, down from a peak near 2.87 at the start of July but still above its 20-day average of 2.19. That places the current reading roughly one standard deviation below that average — less defensive than it was two weeks ago, but the overall skew remains clearly protective relative to the year's range of 0.62 to 3.27. Traders appear to be unwinding some downside hedges ahead of the print rather than adding fresh ones.
The Street leans bullish, with seven buy ratings against three holds and a mean price target of $242, implying roughly 23% upside from Tuesday's close of $196. Barclays raised its target to $260 from $255 on July 15, maintaining its Overweight stance — a modest but timely vote of confidence days before results. Wells Fargo moved in the opposite direction last week, trimming to $202 from $208 while keeping a neutral Equal-Weight rating, and its target sits barely above the current price. That split captures the wider debate well: bulls point to premium luxury sales momentum and AutoNation's used-vehicle sourcing through Webuyyourcar.com, while bears flag a projected 12.9% EBITDA decline for Q4 2025 and an expected $370 year-over-year drop in new gross profit per unit for fiscal 2026. On valuation, AutoNation trades at a PE of 8.3x — compressed enough that the bull case essentially argues the market is pricing in more deterioration than will materialise. The EPS surprise factor score of 79 out of 100 supports the idea that the company has a track record of beating lowered bars.
Cascade Investment holds a dominant 21% of shares, providing a stable ownership anchor. Among active managers, Goldman Sachs Asset Management added roughly 279,000 shares in the April reporting period and Alyeska Investment Group added nearly 590,000 shares in Q1 — two meaningful accumulations from sophisticated buyers. Dimensional and State Street also added modestly in the most recent quarter, suggesting broad-based institutional interest rather than concentrated conviction.
The last earnings print on May 1 delivered a 4.6% one-day drop. The prior Q4 release in late April produced a modest 0.8% gain on the day. With short interest elevated relative to a month ago, the borrow market loose, and the Street still constructively positioned, the more interesting question heading into July 23 is whether the gross profit per unit story — the bear's primary concern — lands better or worse than the cautious guidance already embedded in consensus.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open AN on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
