Brilliant Earth Group heads into its June earnings window with a curious split: borrowing costs have doubled over the past month while the actual short position has quietly unwound.
The most striking data point in the lending market is the cost-to-borrow trajectory. At 5.45% annualised, the borrow rate has more than doubled since early March, when it was running below 2.6%. Yet availability remains extremely loose — the lending pool is barely being tapped, with the borrow market nowhere near the tightest levels seen over the past year. That combination — rising cost, loose availability — points to a repricing of borrow rather than a supply squeeze. The stock is simply more expensive to short than it was two months ago, even as the actual demand for borrows has receded.
Short interest itself tells a story of retreat. At roughly 0.8% of free float, the short position is genuinely small and has fallen sharply — down 26% over the past month from a peak near 170,000 shares in late March to around 123,000 now. The ORTEX short score of 31.8 reflects that: well below the levels that would flag real short-side conviction. Days to cover of roughly four days, per FINRA's most recent fortnightly settlement, confirms the position is neither large nor sticky. This is not a shorted stock; the bears have largely moved on.
Options positioning does nothing to disturb that picture. The put/call ratio of 0.008 is fractionally below its 20-day average of 0.009 — a z-score of -0.25 — meaning options traders are essentially flat relative to recent norms. The 52-week PCR high of 0.18 puts the current reading in perspective: there is almost no hedging activity here, and what little exists sits overwhelmingly in calls. For a stock trading at $1.44 and up 11% over the past month, the options market is reflecting a recovery narrative rather than a defensive one.
The Street is cautious but not hostile. The most recent round of analyst moves came in early March, when B. Riley cut its rating to Neutral with a $1.50 target and Keybanc dropped to Sector Weight — both moves coming off the back of weak results. TD Cowen trimmed its target to $1.60 while holding at Hold. With the analyst data now around 47 days old, the current consensus mean target of $1.71 represents about 19% upside from Tuesday's close of $1.44 — plausible but built on a fragile foundation. The bull case rests on revenue growth of around 4% in FY26 and a modest EBITDA margin of 2.7% for FY25. Bears point to discretionary spending risk, rising commodity costs, and a business model exposed to macro headwinds through both online-only sales and jewellery demand. The EV/EBITDA multiple has compressed slightly over the past month to around 4.3x, and the PE at 14.8x is creeping higher as earnings estimates inch up.
Insider activity adds a note of caution to the recovery story. The most recent logged transaction was COO Sharon Dziesietnik selling 19,687 shares in February at $1.37 — a small deal in dollar terms ($26,971) but part of a consistent pattern of COO and CFO sales stretching back through 2025. No insider has been a net buyer in the data window. Columbia Management added 28,100 shares in Q1 2026 and the firm's position of around 5.1% makes it the most active institutional holder recently; but with only 37 institutions on the register and total holdings small, the ownership base is thin.
The next scheduled earnings event is June 17. With short interest low, borrow costs elevated relative to recent history but still moderate in absolute terms, and the options market showing no defensive build-up, the setup heading into that print is one of muted positioning rather than strong conviction in either direction. What the June report will need to show — and what the Street has not yet seen — is evidence that the margin recovery story is real and not just a function of cost-cutting.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open BRLT on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
