Employers Holdings heads into mid-May with short sellers quietly unwinding after a post-earnings spike — and the stock bouncing hard enough to raise questions about whether the bear case has run its course.
The week told an interesting story on price. EIG closed at $42.01, up more than 21% on the week. That follows a bruising month — the stock had shed roughly 38% over the prior four weeks. The Q1 earnings print on April 29 delivered an immediate blow of -2.8% on the day and -4.5% over the following five sessions. That reaction now looks like the low point. The snapback this week, while dramatic in percentage terms, still leaves the stock well below where it was trading before the tariff-shock selloff of early April.
Short interest tells a cleaner story than the price action might suggest. At 6.4% of free float as of May 7, shorts are meaningful but retreating. The peak came in mid-April, when SI reached 7.6% of float — a level that appeared to anticipate a weak print. After earnings confirmed the bears' thesis, short covering accelerated. SI has dropped roughly 130 basis points from that April 10 high, and the pace of unwinding picked up this week. The borrow market reflects the same dynamic: cost to borrow eased sharply to 0.36% by May 7, down nearly 50% from intraweek highs above 0.70%. Availability is loose — there is no squeeze pressure in this lending pool. The short score of 44 sits in the lower half of the ORTEX universe, consistent with a position that is elevated but not extreme.
Options positioning has shifted materially toward calls. The put/call ratio now reads 3.74 — still above 1, meaning more puts than calls in absolute terms, but dramatically lower than the 20-day mean of 7.87. That ratio had peaked above 28 in late April. The reset is striking: options traders who had been loading on downside protection heading into earnings have not renewed those positions at anywhere near the same intensity. The z-score of -0.76 places current PCR well below recent norms, the lowest reading in the past 52 weeks. That shift is consistent with reduced near-term fear, though the elevated absolute level still reflects residual caution.
The Street picture is thin on fresh input. The most recent analyst action on record was Truist Securities lifting its Buy-rated target to $58 in November 2024 — a level that now looks stale given the stock's descent to $42. The analyst data cited predates the current price environment by more than six months, so any target-price framing should be treated as historical context rather than a live view. The consensus mean target of $46.50 implies modest upside from current levels, but that figure reflects a limited coverage base and no recent revisions. The ORTEX EPS surprise score sits at the 66th percentile, suggesting the company has generally beaten estimates — which makes the April 29 miss-and-drop a relative anomaly worth noting. The forward yield of 3.26% offers some support at current prices, though the dividend history in the snapshot is dated to 2022, and investors should verify current payout status independently.
Insider activity in late February and March was net negative. Seven C-suite executives, including CEO Katherine Antonello, sold shares on March 18 at $39.04. Antonello's sale was the most significant at roughly $205,000 worth of stock. Against that, CFO Michael Pedraja bought 2,000 shares in late February at $39.73 — a modest but directional counterpoint. The net 90-day insider position is positive at roughly $1.1 million, though that figure is skewed by the timing of the CFO purchase relative to the cluster of March sales.
Closest peers diverged sharply on the week. CNA Financial fell 9.4% — the steepest drop in the peer group — while Mercury General and Selective Insurance each added around 3.5%. Aflac was broadly flat. EIG's 21% gain stands out in isolation, though the magnitude reflects recovery from an oversold position rather than a divergence from sector fundamentals. Next earnings are calendared for July 29 — that is where the next key test of whether the April reset reflected a one-time miss or something more structural will arrive.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open EIG on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
