HSY heads into the back half of May with short sellers quietly rebuilding positions and a wall of analyst target cuts — yet the stock itself has barely moved.
Short interest has climbed meaningfully in recent weeks. It now runs at roughly 6.9% of free float, up from around 4.9% in early April — a near-40% jump in position size over six weeks. The pace picked up sharply this month: SI rose 7% week-on-week and is up nearly 14% versus a month ago, making it one of the more sustained bear-position builds among staples names. The intraday pullback on May 19 was modest and likely routine, not a sign of conviction reversing.
The lending market tells a looser story. Despite the SI build, borrow availability is wide open — over 900% of current short interest is available in the lending pool, the tightest the 52-week range goes is still above 400%. Cost to borrow is 0.42%, barely above the risk-free floor, confirming there is no squeeze dynamic and no scramble for supply. Shorts are not fighting a crowded tape for access. Options sentiment backs the muted read: the put/call ratio is 0.85, almost exactly in line with its 20-day average of 0.85, with a z-score near zero. Neither options buyers nor short sellers are showing urgency here.
The Street's tone has tilted cautious, though the bears are not dominating. Across the past three weeks, nearly every analyst who published on cut their price target — JPMorgan, Wells Fargo, UBS, Barclays, and DA Davidson all trimmed, with cuts ranging from 5% to 9%. The lone upgrade came from TD Cowen, which moved to Buy on May 1 with a $210 target. Mizuho is the most recent action, lowering its target from $195 to $185 this morning while holding Neutral. With 16 Hold ratings against just 4 Buys, consensus is firmly neutral at best. The mean price target of $217 sits about 12.5% above the $192.80 close — suggesting the Street still sees upside on paper, but the direction of travel is clearly downward. On valuation, the P/E is running around 21.4x and EV/EBITDA near 13.9x; the EV/EBITDA multiple is slightly lower over 30 days, which offers some marginal support to the bull case. Factor scores flag two genuine standouts: HSY ranks in the 97th percentile on dividend score and the 92nd percentile on analyst recommendation divergence — meaning the bull/bear debate is genuinely wider than usual among those covering the name.
Insider selling has been consistent this week. The Milton Hershey School Trust has been steadily offloading small parcels every session — several hundred to a few thousand shares at a time across May 14 and 15, all priced in the $186–$196 range. The CFO also sold 1,500 shares on May 18 at $186.25. None of these are individually alarming at current valuation, and the Trust's 27.7% stake (56.3 million shares) makes routine rebalancing sales structurally expected. But the pattern is one of distribution, not accumulation, and it mirrors the broader tone across all holder data.
Q2 results are pencilled in for July 30. The most recent earnings print on May 5 produced a +2.4% next-day move, recovering from the April 30 report which dropped 3.6%. What to watch is whether the ongoing SI build — running at six-week highs and still accelerating — continues into the next cycle, and whether any of the Hold-heavy analyst community finds cause to upgrade given the stock's proximity to individual firm target floors.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open HSY on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
