SMCI has lost momentum since last week's post-earnings note: the stock is down 7% on the week to $30.56, the short cover that defined the May 5 reaction has effectively paused, and options traders just printed the most defensive put/call reading of the past year.
The options signal is the sharpest data point this week. The put/call ratio jumped to 0.92 — more than three standard deviations above its 20-day average of 0.78, and the highest reading in the past 52 weeks. That gap from the prior-day reading of 0.77 is stark; it landed in a single session, suggesting a rapid re-hedging rather than a gradual drift. Whatever drove the move — the weekly price decline, sector-wide hardware pressure, or positioning ahead of the August earnings date — options traders are materially more defensive than at any point in the last year.
Short interest tells a more stable story, but the cover narrative from last week has stalled. SI edged fractionally higher on the day to 13.0% of the free float, roughly flat on the week. That is a meaningful change from the prior note, which described sharp reactive closures in the immediate post-earnings window: the short base had fallen from ~87 million shares to ~78.7 million through May 11. Since then, shorts haven't rebuilt aggressively, but they haven't continued to exit either. The borrow market remains loose — availability is running at 205%, up 18% on the week, and well above the 52-week low of 85%. Cost to borrow dropped another 17% on the week to 0.35%. That combination — wide availability, cheap borrow — means new short positions face no friction to enter if sentiment deteriorates further.
The Street's reaction to the May 5 earnings print was broadly positive but not uniformly bullish. Most firms lifted targets: Mizuho raised to $36 from $30, Rosenblatt moved to $40, JP Morgan went to $32 from $28, and Citi pushed to $31. Barclays and Wedbush were the exceptions, both trimming targets to $34. The consensus is Hold, with no Buys on the broader count and a mean target of $36.75 — roughly 20% above the current $30.56 price. At a forward PE of 10.8 and EV/EBITDA of 7.1, the valuation is not demanding. The PE has contracted about 0.9x over the past month as the stock gave back some of its post-earnings gains, though the bull case still centres on AI infrastructure demand, strong order backlog, and a manufacturing footprint that insulates somewhat from tariff risk. The bear case focuses on supply constraints, customer concentration, and legal overhangs that haven't fully cleared.
The institutional picture adds some texture. Founder and CEO Charles Liang holds 8.9% of shares, essentially unchanged, and the insider activity on May 8 was largely routine awards with token sales from senior VPs — nothing directionally significant. BlackRock added 1.7 million shares through April-end, while Marshall Wace entered or substantially built a position of 7.1 million shares, a notable new presence. Morgan Stanley trimmed by 3.1 million shares over the same period. Those crosscurrents reflect a stock where passive flows are mildly accumulating and at least one active manager is stepping in, but where some selling pressure from other institutions persists.
Peer performance reinforces the week's soft tone. DELL fell 1.5% on the week, and QMCO dropped 13.8%. SMCI's 7% weekly decline sits roughly in the middle of that range — consistent with sector-wide hardware selling rather than any SMCI-specific deterioration. The next earnings event is scheduled for August 4. Between now and then, the watch point is whether options defensiveness is a one-day spike or the start of a sustained re-hedging cycle — and whether the short base, currently at a plateau, resumes its post-earnings unwind or begins to rebuild.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open SMCI on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
