Rush Street Interactive heads into its June 3 earnings with a striking disconnect: a massive wave of insider selling on one side, and options traders at their most bullish in months on the other.
The insider activity is the headline this week. On May 5-6, Executive Chairman and co-founder Neil Bluhm sold more than 10.5 million shares at $24.96, a transaction valued at roughly $262 million. CEO and co-founder Richard Todd Schwartz sold an additional 408,000 shares for about $10.2 million over the same two days. COO Mattias Stetz added a further $2.1 million in sales. In total, insiders offloaded over $275 million worth of stock — predominantly from the two founders — in a concentrated two-day window. These were pre-planned disposals at prices well below the current level of $28, suggesting they were scheduled before the April earnings beat drove the stock up 15% in a single session. Still, the scale of founder selling at this point in the rally is notable context for anyone assessing long-term conviction at the top.
Options traders have drawn the opposite conclusion. The put/call ratio has collapsed to 0.21, more than 1.7 standard deviations below its 20-day average of 0.49 — the lowest defensive reading in months, and a sharp reversal from the cautious 0.73 registered on April 30. The market is pricing calls heavily over puts, reflecting confidence ahead of next month's update. That optimism follows the April 28 earnings print, where the stock jumped 15% the next day and added a further 20% over the following week. If the next print delivers anything comparable, options holders are well-positioned. The 52-week PCR low of 0.03 shows there is still theoretical room for the ratio to compress further, but the current reading already reflects materially bullish positioning.
Short interest is elevated but not extreme, and the borrow market is relaxed. SI runs at roughly 7.5% of free float — up approximately 28% over the past month, driven by a step-change in early May from around 5.7% to above 7%. That month-on-month jump is worth watching, but it follows the post-earnings stock surge: shorts may have been rebuilding into price strength rather than expressing fresh conviction. Borrowing costs are low at 0.36% APR despite a 21% week-on-week rise. Availability is exceptionally loose at 949% — nearly ten shares available to borrow for every one already lent out — meaning there is ample room for short positions to grow without squeezing the lending market.
The Street is broadly constructive and growing more so. Following the April earnings beat, analysts across Citizens, Macquarie, Jefferies, Needham, Wells Fargo, Oppenheimer, Benchmark, and Susquehanna all raised price targets — most by $3-8 — while maintaining positive ratings. The consensus mean target now runs at $30.09, roughly 7.5% above the current price. JPMorgan remains the notable outlier, sitting at Neutral with a $21 target set in April — well below peers and implying the stock is already fairly valued. The bull case rests on 66% gross gaming revenue growth in fiscal 2025, a 34% increase in monthly active users, and strong Latin American expansion. Bears flag market share headwinds as states limit licensed operators, alongside VAT pressures on deposits. Valuation is stretched: the P/E runs above 40x and the price-to-book ratio is above 25x, with both multiples rising roughly 10% and 17% respectively over the past 30 days. EPS momentum factor scores are exceptional — 94th percentile over 30 days — but the 12-month forward EPS growth rank is near the bottom at the 25th percentile, a flag that near-term profit visibility may not keep pace with the stock's re-rating.
Among correlated peers, CZR added 8.2% on the week and PENN gained 2.6%, both benefiting from the broader gaming sector tailwind. KAMBI outperformed all of them at nearly 5.9%. BRSL was the notable laggard, down 8.1%. RSI's own 1.8% weekly gain looks modest relative to this peer group — the stock appears to be digesting its 22% one-month run rather than continuing to lead.
The June 3 earnings call is the next pivot point: the question is whether the revenue and user growth trajectory that produced a 15% single-day reaction in April holds up, and whether the founder selling that preceded it changes the narrative around insider conviction at current prices.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open RSI on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
