MFA Financial enters its May 5 Q1 earnings date with a notably cleaner setup than it carried through most of April — short sellers have been cutting positions, call demand has overtaken puts, and the stock has added 2.2% on the week to close at $10.29.
The most striking shift in positioning is the rapid unwind of short interest. SI % of FF dropped 15.7% over the past week to 2.6% of the free float — a meaningful retreat from the mid-April peak where shares short were running closer to 3.1 million. That pullback reverses a spike that had built through the first half of the month. Borrow conditions remain loose throughout: cost to borrow has edged up to 0.51% — a six-week high — but that is still a negligible carry. Availability is equally unthreatening, with the lending pool far from stressed and the ORTEX short score easing to 32.5, down from 34.4 ten days ago. The direction of travel is clear: shorts are exiting, not adding.
Options positioning reinforces the same read, though from an unusual angle. The put/call ratio has dropped to 0.59 — the lowest of the past 52 weeks, and 1.3 standard deviations below its 20-day average of 0.68. That means call volume is running at its most dominant relative to puts all year. For a mortgage REIT approaching an earnings print, that is a notably constructive posture from the options market. The prior-week readings, which sat closer to 0.69-0.70, made the shift all the more abrupt. Whatever drove hedging demand through late March and early April has largely dissipated.
The Street is less enthusiastic. The most recent analyst moves — RBC Capital lifting its target to $11 in early March and Keefe Bruyette & Woods matching that in February — kept ratings squarely in neutral territory, and those are the freshest data points available. The mean price target from those coverage updates sits around $11, implying modest upside from the current $10.29 print. The bull case centres on MFA's pivot toward agency assets, improved 60-day delinquency trends, and management's stated aim of protecting book value. Bears point to persistent unrealized losses weighing on GAAP earnings and lingering questions around the company's ability to scale its capital base without lifting operating costs. The price-to-book multiple has expanded about 7% over the past month to roughly 0.78x — still a discount, but the direction of travel has improved. EPS surprise ranks in the 90th percentile of the universe, which lends some credibility to the bull case on fundamentals.
Institutional ownership provides one genuinely interesting data point. CEO Craig Knutson appears in the top-holder list with 1.18 million shares, and the most recent filing shows his position increased by 557,743 shares — a meaningful addition for a stock in this price range. Vanguard and BlackRock together hold roughly 19% of shares outstanding, with both adding modestly in their latest reported periods. The ownership base is stable and incrementally supportive.
Among close peers, CIM gained 3.6% on the week and LADR added 2.2%, broadly in line with MFA's 2.2% move. NLY and AGNC lagged slightly at around 1.0% and 1.6% respectively, suggesting the sector-wide bid has been relatively uniform rather than stock-specific. The May 5 earnings call is therefore the next meaningful catalyst — and given the recent pattern of muted one-day reactions (a 1.4% decline after the most recent print, a 1.3% gain before that), the market will be focused less on the headline number and more on management's commentary around agency allocation, delinquency trends, and dividend sustainability.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open MFA on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
