Johnson Controls International enters its next earnings print — scheduled for June 1 — with a freshly upgraded analyst consensus and a stock that has recovered sharply off its lows, leaving the Street debating whether the move has now outpaced the fundamental improvement.
The most active debate is happening at the analyst level. After the May 6 earnings beat — organic sales grew 6% against a 4.2% consensus estimate — most covering firms raised their price targets. UBS moved highest of the post-earnings revisions, lifting its target to $170 while reiterating Buy, and Wells Fargo nudged its Overweight target up to $160. RBC and Citigroup also raised targets but held more cautious ratings, with RBC at Sector Perform ($154) and Citi at Neutral ($155). That cluster of target raises was followed this week by a quiet RBC reiteration with no change at $154 — read as the Street consolidating rather than pressing higher. The mean analyst target now stands at $150.85, just 7.6% above the current price of $140.22. That modest gap, combined with multiple neutral/in-line ratings in the mix, suggests the Street has marked up the story without going fully conviction-long.
The bear case is not without substance. BNP Paribas initiated in mid-April with an Underperform and a $120 target — roughly 14% below current levels. The bear argument centres on below-100% free cash flow conversion, margin pressure, and organic order weakness in APAC, where systems sales fell 16% in the most recent quarter. EV/EBITDA trades near 20x on forward estimates, and the EV/EBIT implied by reported data runs higher still. Those aren't cheap multiples for a business with mixed cash flow quality and a contested growth trajectory. The bull-bear spread is wide, and with June 1 only days away, that disagreement is what makes the setup interesting.
Short sellers, for now, are a marginal part of the picture. Short interest runs at just 1.4% of the free float — low by any measure — and eased roughly 3% over the past week even as it climbed 15% over the past month, partially reflecting a build-up after the May earnings reaction. With borrow availability at essentially unlimited levels and cost to borrow below 0.5%, there is no squeeze dynamic and no material short-side pressure. The ORTEX short score of 30 confirms this: shorts are present but not a driving force. The options market adds a mild hedge overlay — the put/call ratio ticked down to 1.07 on Tuesday from a run near 1.22 mid-week last week, suggesting some defensive positioning was put on around the PCR's 52-week high, then partially unwound as the stock rebounded.
On the insider side, the recent data skews toward selling. A division president, Lei Zhang Schlitz, sold roughly $10.5 million worth of shares across multiple transactions on May 8, shortly after the earnings event. A second divisional president sold a smaller parcel the following week at $145. CEO Joakim Weidemanis sold a modest position in March. Net insider sales over the past 90 days total roughly $17 million. These are not emergency-type disposals — the trade significance scores are low and the volumes are small relative to total float — but the direction is consistently outward, not inward.
The last two earnings prints both produced negative one-day reactions, with the stock falling roughly 3.8% after Q2 results in May and 1.7% after Q1 in March. Five-day returns after both events were also negative, though moderate. Peer performance gives additional context: Trane Technologies added just 0.2% on the week, while Carrier Global gained 0.6% — both meaningful underperformers relative to JCI's 3.5% weekly gain. Modine Manufacturing surged nearly 20% on the week on its own catalyst, which may account for some sector noise. JCI's outperformance against its closest HVAC correlates looks idiosyncratic rather than sector-driven.
The June 1 print is therefore less about whether the building automation cycle is intact — the Q2 beat settled that in the near term — and more about whether APAC orders have stabilised and whether free cash flow is tracking to a level that justifies the current multiple.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open JCI on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
