Cogent Communications heads into its Q1 2026 results — due May 4 — with a striking divergence in play: short sellers have been cutting exposure at pace while the stock has rebounded sharply, yet the last earnings print was among the most violent on record for the name.
The short-covering story is the headline. Short interest has fallen from roughly 15.5% of free float in mid-March to 11.6% today — a decline of nearly four percentage points in six weeks. The sharpest move came around April 9-10, when positions dropped by almost two full percentage points in a single session. At the March peak, shorts were running close to their highest readings in over a year; now the short score has eased to 55.9, down from above 58 a week ago. Borrow availability remains loose — lending pool availability is well above stressed levels, with cost to borrow only 0.56% annually — confirming this is genuine covering, not a forced squeeze. Shorts are choosing to exit.
The options market tells a completely different story. Rather than hedging into a historically risky event, call positioning is dominant. The put/call ratio is just 0.11, barely above the 20-day average of 0.10, and almost at the 52-week low of 0.096. Two standard deviations above the mean would register defensiveness; this reading is effectively at the floor. Options traders are not reaching for protection ahead of May 4 — a notable contrast to how cautious a rational actor might be, given the February print.
That February print is worth sitting with. When CCOI last reported — Q4 2025 results on February 20 — the stock fell 32% in a single day and lost nearly 29% over the following week. The prior comparable event, in late February 2026, showed a 19.6% one-day gain. The range of outcomes here is genuinely extreme: the last two earnings reactions span roughly fifty percentage points. The stock has since recovered much of that crash, closing at $24.21 — up 37% from the February low — which itself frames the stakes heading into Monday's call.
The Street remains cautious in aggregate, though its analyst data trails the stock's recovery. Following the February crash, a wave of target cuts arrived: Oppenheimer held its Outperform but slashed from $40 to $30; Keybanc kept Overweight but cut from $30 to $25; Wells Fargo lowered to $23, maintaining Equal-Weight. RBC followed in mid-March, trimming to $22 at Sector Perform. The consensus mean target of around $26.60 now sits only modestly above the current price, leaving limited stated upside even from the bulls. The EV/EBITDA multiple is running at 11.2x, down slightly over the past month as the stock recovered from depressed levels. The negative PE and price-to-book reflect the leverage structure characteristic of Cogent's model, not unusual for the sector.
On the ownership side, BlackRock and Vanguard both added shares through March — incrementally, consistent with index rebalancing rather than conviction buying. Founder and CEO David Schaeffer trimmed roughly 58,700 shares in early April, a modest reduction. The CFO sold 4,850 shares in early March. The insider activity is at low significance levels and reads more like routine liquidity than directional positioning. Meanwhile, Skylands Capital sold 44,750 shares last week, adding to a thin but consistent stream of institutional trimming noted in recent filings.
With Q1 results four days away, what matters most is whether the data-center connectivity business is inflecting — the key bull thesis — or whether the revenue trajectory from the Sprint legacy integration continues to disappoint, as the bears argued after February. The answer, once again, will likely arrive with a swing.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open CCOI on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
