Copart heads into its May 14 earnings report with short sellers quietly reducing exposure — even as the stock trades well below where most analysts see fair value.
Short positioning has been on a steady retreat. SI % FF dropped from a recent peak near 4.0% in early April to 3.4% now, a decline of roughly 15% over the month. The week-on-week move mirrors that direction, down 5.4% to sit at 29.9 million shares. That easing trend is the clearest message in the data right now: short sellers who rushed in during the early-April market stress are stepping back. Borrow conditions support that read — cost to borrow is cheap at 0.44%, and availability in the lending pool is extremely loose. The availability figure means there is ample supply of shares to borrow relative to current short interest, so there is no mechanical pressure squeezing shorts out. Options traders echo the calm: the put/call ratio of 0.42 is fractionally below its 20-day average of 0.44, putting it essentially inline with recent norms and nowhere near the defensive extremes seen last autumn when the PCR touched 1.14.
The Street is more cautious than the lending market. The most recent analyst actions, clustered around last February's Q2 print, were unanimously cuts. JP Morgan trimmed its target from $45 to $34 while holding Neutral; Barclays nudged its target down to $32, keeping its Underweight rating; and Baird lowered to $48 despite maintaining Outperform. The consensus mean target of $42.67 implies roughly 28% upside from the current $33.33 close — but that number is partly a function of higher targets set before the stock de-rated, so the gap may flatter actual Street conviction. Valuation sits at a P/E of 20.7x and EV/EBITDA of 14.2x, both modestly higher than a month ago as the stock recovered from its early-April lows. Bulls point to Copart's online auction platform, rising global average selling prices, and a growing international buyer base — now 38% of units sold. Bears flag depressed unit growth and slippage in gross transaction value per lot, worrying that volume headwinds may be structural rather than cyclical.
Insider activity adds texture but no dramatic signal. CEO Jeffrey Liaw sold roughly $870,000 worth of stock on April 15 — the latest in a series of quarterly sell-downs at regular intervals, most likely a pre-planned programme. The pattern has repeated each quarter at progressively lower prices: $44.79 in October, $40.17 in January, $33.18 in April. That declining sale price alongside a continued pattern of selling is worth noting, though the trade significance scores are low and the volumes are a small fraction of his total holding.
Peer performance diverged this week. WCN gained 4.6% and RBA added 2.5%, while Copart gave up 1.0%. Copart's mild underperformance against those names — both in diversified support services — suggests the stock is carrying some company-specific drag ahead of the earnings date, rather than reflecting a broad sector move.
The May 14 print is the next hard catalyst. After February's Q2 result the stock fell 3.4% on the day and slid a further 1.6% over the following week, leaving the recent reaction profile negative at short horizons. What to watch: whether unit volume shows any recovery from the depressed levels flagged in the last two calls, and how management frames demand from international buyers as the dollar and global used-car markets remain in flux.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open CPRT on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
