MUSA arrives at its April 30 Q1 earnings call carried by a wave of analyst upgrades — yet with short interest quietly rising and the last print delivering a sharp earnings miss.
Options traders are the most bullish they have been in months. The put/call ratio has dropped to 0.47, nearly 1.3 standard deviations below its 20-day average of 0.69, reflecting unusually strong demand for upside exposure into the event. That optimism runs across the analyst community too. BofA upgraded the stock to Neutral from Underperform in the week before earnings, simultaneously lifting its price target from $350 to $550 — a $200 move that signals a meaningful reversal of prior scepticism. Keybanc, already at Overweight, raised its target to $600. JP Morgan initiated coverage at Overweight with a $539 target in late March. At the consensus mean of $514, targets and the current price of $514.45 are almost exactly aligned, meaning the Street's aggregate view leaves essentially no upside from here — though the bullish outliers sit well above that level.
Short interest is building quietly beneath the bullish surface, however. Bears have added exposure steadily since mid-April, with SI % of free float climbing to 5.8% — up roughly 5% on the week and coming after a sharp unwind that pulled the measure down nearly 18% over the prior month. The borrow market remains loose. Cost to borrow is only 0.54%, and availability remains wide, so new shorts are entering without any squeeze pressure. This is not yet an aggressive positioning shift, but the direction is clear: after a month of de-risking, shorts have started rebuilding.
The disagreement centres on fuel margins and volumes. Bulls point to improving fuel margin trends in Q2 — up 3 cents per gallon quarter-on-quarter — and continued momentum in food and beverage sales. Bears anchor on the Q4 print: EBITDA came in at $157 million, 20% below consensus, with retail fuel volumes down 1.9% and same-store fuel volume falling 4.2%. That miss sent the stock down 15% in a single session. Today it trades at $514, having recovered most of that ground, with EPS momentum ranking in the 89th percentile over the past 30 days and forward EPS growth estimates in the 99th percentile — factors that justified the analyst upgrades but also raise the bar for the print.
The Q1 report is therefore a test of whether Murphy's margin recovery is real, sustained, and sufficient to justify a stock that trades precisely at consensus — with analysts freshly upgraded but short sellers quietly returning to their positions.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open MUSA on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
