Cracker Barrel Old Country Store heads into its June 9 earnings release as one of the most heavily shorted names in the restaurant sector, with short sellers showing no sign of retreat.
Short interest has climbed to 26.3% of the free float — up more than 20% over the past month — and the ORTEX short score has ticked higher each session this week to reach 71.8, placing CBRL in the 7th percentile of all stocks by that measure. That's a crowded, convicted short position by any standard. Yet the borrow market tells a more nuanced story. Availability has loosened considerably in recent weeks, running at roughly 141% — meaning there are about 1.4 shares available for every one already borrowed — well above the 52-week trough of 14.8%. Cost to borrow is modest at 1.1%, with little volatility. Bears have plenty of room to press further without triggering a supply squeeze. The stock itself gained 13.4% over the past month to $33.54, though it has slipped back modestly over the past week — a recovery that has brought it just above the consensus mean price target of $31.75.
Options positioning is the one angle that cuts against the bearish grain. The put/call ratio has eased to 0.86, slightly below its 20-day average of 0.87 and near the lower end of recent ranges, suggesting options traders are not adding fresh downside protection into the print. That's a mild contrast to what the short book implies — either a sign that options markets are complacent, or that some hedging is being done through the borrow market rather than puts.
The analyst community is split but mostly cautious. BofA Securities raised its target from $31 to $34 on June 5 while maintaining an Underperform rating — a tacit acknowledgment that the stock has run ahead of fundamentals. Citigroup and multiple other names carry outright Sell or Underperform ratings, with targets clustered well below the current price. Only Truist maintains a Buy with a $47 target, resting on the bull case that loyalty program traction, menu innovation, and a labour restructuring payoff can drive a genuine margin recovery. Bears counter that traffic remains deeply impaired — still down materially from pre-controversy levels — and that Cracker Barrel's exposure to lower-income, non-local travellers makes it acutely sensitive to any softening in consumer discretionary spending. The negative earnings yield and an EV/EBITDA near 15x on a business generating losses offer little valuation cushion. DRI and BJRI, the closest correlated peers, both fell sharply on the week — down 5.4% and 7.7% respectively — while CBRL held in comparatively better, a divergence that the print will need to justify.
The June 9 report is a direct test of whether the recent price recovery reflects genuine operating improvement or simply a short-term squeeze in a heavily contested name.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open CBRL on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
