Pershing Square Inc. enters the second week of July with a sharp disconnect between a freshly-covered analyst community and a lending market that remains deeply hostile to the stock.
The Street coverage is brand new. Jones Trading initiated with a Buy and a $39 target just this week — the most recent in a wave of initiations that launched in late May. Citi and Loop Capital came in at $50 and $49 respectively, both Buy-rated. UBS and RBC held back, initiating at Neutral and Sector Perform with targets of $39 and $40. Wells Fargo sat closest to the current price with an Equal-Weight and a $37 target. The consensus mean lands at $42 — implying roughly 27% upside from Tuesday's close of $32.97. Yet the stock is down 7.8% over the past month and fell 6.8% in a single session on July 7. That gap between the analyst community's optimism and the market's behaviour is the defining tension right now.
The lending market is where bears have had the most conviction. Borrow costs, though easing, are still extraordinary — 236% annualised cost to borrow is not a number you see on ordinary equity. It has come down from above 330% in early June, a meaningful retreat, but it remains punishingly high for anyone looking to establish or maintain a short position. Availability is tight at roughly 29%, meaning fewer than one share is available for every three already lent out — well below the normal range and consistent with a borrow pool under real stress. The 52-week low hit 9% back on June 1, so the current level is loose by recent standards, but the direction of travel in the past week has been toward tighter conditions again, with availability falling from 34.7% on July 3 to 28.9% today. Short shares outstanding have climbed about 23% over the past month, though they eased roughly 11% week-on-week, suggesting some shorts covered into the recent weakness.
Options traders are less worked up than the borrow market implies. The put/call ratio has actually pulled back to 1.31 after running as high as 1.54 in late June — almost exactly in line with the 20-day average of 1.30, with a z-score near zero. That's notable: despite the sharp Tuesday selloff, the options market is not registering fresh panic. The put-to-call ratio had been elevated for about two weeks and has now normalised, which tells a calmer story than the headline price action or the borrow costs would suggest.
The ownership picture makes PS unusual for a listed vehicle. Founder and CEO Bill Ackman holds roughly 24% of shares, and Pershing Square Capital Management as a firm controls another 46%. That extreme insider concentration means the effective tradeable float is thin — which partly explains why borrow costs are so extreme and why availability stays persistently low. The only meaningful third-party institutional name in the top holders is Consulta Master Fund, holding a sub-1% position. Ackman himself bought roughly $19 million worth of shares at prices between $22.60 and $24.20 back in late April, a signal that management viewed the mid-$20s as attractive. The stock has since risen well above those levels but gave back a chunk of that gain in Tuesday's session.
Valuation multiples are in flux. The P/E has compressed by roughly 11 points over the past 30 days to 39.4x, and EV/EBITDA has fallen about 5.5 turns to 30.3x. Those are still rich numbers for an asset manager — the bear case centres precisely on valuation. The ORTEX short score has been remarkably stable, hovering in the 62-63 range for the past two weeks, reflecting neither meaningful deterioration nor relief across the underlying signal components.
The key variable to watch is whether the fresh analyst coverage — all of it initiated within the past seven weeks, none of it tested through a meaningful down move — holds its targets as the discount-to-NAV dynamic evolves and the stock continues to trade materially below the most bullish price targets.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open PS on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
