Pershing Square Inc. heads into its June 22 earnings report with the borrow market cooling from its peak — but remaining one of the most expensive shorts in the market.
The lending picture has shifted since the previous earnings preview. Cost to borrow has eased to 250% from above 293% a week ago, and availability has loosened materially — rising to 40% from a mid-week low near 22%. That is still tight: roughly two shares available for every three already lent out. What is notable is the direction. Short interest fell nearly 20% in a single session on June 16, dropping to around 490,000 shares — its lowest reading in over a month. Shorts are no longer trimming at the margin; they are covering in size. The ORTEX short score holds steady near 61, suggesting the broader positioning picture has not shifted dramatically, but the sharp single-day reduction in shares short is the clearest sign yet that bears are reducing exposure ahead of the print.
The analyst debate centres on a straightforward question: does PS trade at a deserved discount, or is the structure itself mispriced? Six firms initiated coverage in late May, and the split was immediate. Citigroup and Loop Capital opened with Buy ratings and targets of $50 and $49 respectively — both implying substantial upside from the current $34.58. UBS and Wells Fargo took the other side, with Neutral and Equal-Weight ratings and targets closer to $37-39. RBC and Oppenheimer landed in the middle with market-perform equivalents. The consensus mean target of $42 now sits about 22% above the current price — a gap that opened up as the stock fell 16% over the past month before recovering 6% this week. Bulls point to the permanent capital structure, Ackman's track record, and a fee model aligned with investor outcomes. Bears flag concentration in three revenue vehicles, the volatility of GAAP earnings driven by mark-to-market performance fees, and the persistent NAV discount.
The ownership structure adds an unusual layer to the setup. William Ackman held 23.7% of shares as of April 30, and he was a buyer in late April — purchasing roughly 800,000 shares at prices between $22 and $24, well below where the stock trades today. Those purchases now sit on a meaningful gain, and insiders collectively added over $19 million net in the 90-day window. That aligns management's interests tightly with the share price outcome, but it also means the float available for short sellers to borrow against is structurally constrained — a partial explanation for why borrow costs remain elevated even as short interest shrinks.
The June 22 print will test whether the recovery from a 16% monthly decline reflects genuine re-rating or simply short covering — and whether the NAV discount that dominated the analyst debate at initiation has narrowed enough to satisfy even the cautious end of a deeply divided Street.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open PS on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
