Old National Bancorp heads into the back half of July with an unusual divergence: options traders have turned sharply more cautious while the short sellers who built up positions through June are steadily covering.
The options move is the standout this week. The put/call ratio jumped to 0.63 on Tuesday — nearly three standard deviations above its 20-day mean of 0.07, and the highest reading in the past year bar a brief spike on June 30. To put that in context, for most of the past month the PCR barely registered above zero; a ratio of 0.63 represents a genuine, sudden shift toward downside protection. Whether that reflects hedging ahead of the Q2 print — earnings landed July 22 — or broader caution on the regional banking space, the options market sent a distinctly defensive signal into the report.
Short interest tells a different story, and the contrast matters. Bears have been retreating since early July. Short interest has fallen nearly 10% on the week and is down roughly 18% over the past month, pulling the short position from around 24.5 million shares in late June to just under 18.6 million now, equivalent to 4.8% of the free float. That unwind looks orderly rather than pressured — borrow costs have eased to 0.41%, their lowest level in six weeks, and availability is loose at around 549%, meaning there are more than five shares available to lend for every one currently borrowed. The ORTEX short score has also trended lower through July, sliding from 53 on July 8 to 46.8 today. Conditions offer no squeeze pressure; the covering appears to be a voluntary reduction in a thesis rather than a forced exit.
The Street remains broadly constructive. Most analysts carry Overweight or Buy ratings, and Barclays lifted its target to $31 earlier this month — the most recent action from a notable firm, keeping ONB above the consensus mean of $28.73. At $26.17, the stock trades roughly 9% below that consensus, implying the market is applying a modest discount to the bullish view. Valuation looks undemanding: the trailing P/E is around 9.5x and the stock changes hands at just over 1x book. The bull case centres on Midwest loan growth, disciplined credit quality, and capital returns. Bears point to margin pressure, sluggish organic growth, and the integration overhang from recent M&A. Factor scores reflect a similar tension — the dividend score ranks in the 96th percentile, forward EPS growth is above average, but the short-score rank (13th percentile) and the DTC rank (6th percentile) both flag that the lending market views this as a relatively uncrowded, low-conviction short.
Among close peers, ONB lagged on the day and the week. ZION fell nearly 4% on Tuesday and is down about 2% on the week, making it the sector's clearest laggard. UBSI, FULT, and SSB each gained between 1% and 2% over the same period. ONB's half-percent weekly decline sits in the middle of the peer group — neither notably weak nor strong — which makes the options spike harder to attribute to a stock-specific catalyst alone and more plausible as a hedge around the earnings print itself.
With Q2 results now just released and the next scheduled event not until October 20, the key question is whether the PCR spike was a one-day earnings hedge that normalises quickly, or whether it marks the start of a sustained shift in sentiment — and whether the short-covering trend resumes or stalls once the market digests the numbers.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open ONB on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
