LendingTree enters the back half of July with short sellers accelerating and options traders the most bearish they have been all year — a dual-pressure setup on a stock that reported disappointing Q2 results this week and is already down 5% on the week.
The most striking development in positioning is the pace of short-interest growth. Shorts now account for nearly 13% of the free float — a level that has almost doubled in a single month, rising 58% from late June. Over the past week alone, the position added roughly 4%, bringing total shares short to approximately 1.75 million. That cumulative build is hard to ignore. Back in mid-June, shorts were running at a fraction of current levels, around 8–9% of float. The acceleration tracks almost precisely with the stock's earnings miss narrative gaining traction. Despite the large short position, the borrow market remains comfortable: availability is running at roughly 374%, meaning there are close to four shares available to borrow for every one already lent out. Cost to borrow has ticked up 22% on the week to 0.45%, but that remains a low absolute rate. There is no squeeze pressure here — the lending pool is well-supplied and newcomers can build shorts cheaply.
Options positioning adds the more striking signal. Put buying has surged in the past two weeks. The put/call ratio hit 1.11 on Tuesday — more than two standard deviations above its 20-day average of 0.61 — and has held above 1.04 for four straight sessions. As recently as mid-July, the PCR was below 0.50. That is a near-doubling in defensive demand in less than two weeks. The 52-week high is 1.37, so the current reading is already deep into the elevated zone, and the trajectory is pointed higher. Taken together with the short-interest build, the two markets are telling the same story: investors are actively loading on protection or outright bearish exposure heading into whatever comes next after Tuesday's earnings release.
The Street is nominally bullish but visibly losing conviction. The most recent analyst action came on July 13, when Keefe, Bruyette & Woods cut its price target from $70 to $58, while holding its Outperform rating. That followed a March trim from $83 to $70 by the same firm. Needham has been stable at $60 since March. The mean target across the Street now sits at roughly $64, implying more than 50% upside from the current $41 close — a gap that normally signals opportunity but in this case more likely reflects targets that have not fully caught up with how far the stock has de-rated. Valuation multiples broadly support the caution: the PE multiple has compressed by 0.28 turns over the past 30 days and P/B has contracted by 0.17. The EV/EBITDA of 5.5x is modest, and the ORTEX short score of 63.5 — a ranking in roughly the 8th percentile for short pressure — confirms that this is a meaningfully shorted name by the wider universe's standards. The bull case rests on insurance segment momentum and margin expansion; the bear case centres on rate sensitivity and the structural challenge of monetising mortgage leads in a flat origination environment.
Peer context sharpens the picture. NerdWallet gained 5% on the week and Encore Capital rose 7.5%. Upstart, SoFi, and Dave all fell between 5% and 7%, tracking TREE lower. The group split neatly along the credit-quality and rate-sensitivity fault line — diversified marketplace names held up; consumer-lending platforms with more direct rate exposure dropped in tandem with TREE.
Institutional ownership offers one counterweight to the overall bearish tilt. BlackRock added 61,000 shares through June 30, Colombia Management added 50,000, and Jennison Associates disclosed a 434,000-share addition earlier in the year. Insider activity is less informative: the only transactions on record in recent months are routine director compensation awards at zero cost, and the CFO sold fewer than 2,000 shares in March. Net insider buying over the trailing 90 days is zero.
The next focal point is how the earnings reaction from Tuesday's release develops over the coming sessions. The stock edged up 1.5% on the day, but the week remains firmly negative, and the prior comparable release in June generated only a muted 1.5% gain before fading to a 0.7% loss on a five-day horizon. With shorts still building, options protection elevated, and analyst targets continuing their long march lower, the key question is whether Tuesday's numbers are enough to arrest the positioning shift — or whether the 58% monthly short-interest build has further to run.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open TREE on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
