PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust enters its August 4 earnings date carrying a stock that has dropped 9% over the past month to $9.79, even as short sellers have been quietly rebuilding positions — a combination worth watching in a name with a live upcoming catalyst.
Short interest has climbed 26% over the past 30 days, reaching 9.2% of the free float. That is a material build, pulling the position back toward levels last seen in early July after a brief consolidation. The week itself was slightly different — shorts trimmed around 4% over the five days to July 28 — suggesting some tactical covering ahead of the print rather than a conviction exit. Borrowing remains cheap at 0.59%, so the cost of maintaining a short position is essentially negligible. Availability is comfortable at 238%, meaning there is no lending squeeze in sight; shorts can add or cover freely without moving the market for borrows.
Options positioning has shifted notably over the past two weeks, and the direction is telling. The put/call ratio has dropped to 1.50, almost 1.4 standard deviations below its 20-day average of 2.08. For context, PMT's 52-week high on this ratio was above 20 — historically the options market has been heavily skewed toward puts. The recent compression suggests investors are buying fewer downside hedges than usual heading into results, or actively rolling calls. That divergence — shorts rebuilding while options traders reduce their defensive posture — is the central tension in this week's setup.
The Street has been consistently negative in direction, though the most recent analyst data is from late May. Piper Sandler and Wells Fargo both cut price targets to $12 after the last earnings print, and KBW downgraded to Market Perform at $12 on May 8. The consensus mean target is $12.11, implying roughly 24% upside from the current $9.79 — but that gap reflects the stock's sharp decline since those targets were set, not fresh bullishness. The valuation tells a similar story: the price-to-book ratio has compressed to 0.66, down around 11% over 30 days, while the P/E has fallen to roughly 7.2x. The dividend score ranks in the 89th percentile across the ORTEX universe, which matters for yield-sensitive holders, though the dividend history data available is stale and predates recent book-value pressure. The short score of 64.5 has crept higher through July — a middling-to-elevated reading that reflects the combination of high SI percentage and weak earnings momentum, with the 90-day EPS momentum score sitting at just 4 out of 100.
Among peers, the week's divergence is notable. RITM rallied nearly 7% on the week and AGNC gained 2.7%. PMT essentially flatlined, down 0.1%. That underperformance relative to the sector's stronger names adds context to the short rebuild: bears appear to be expressing a view that PMT's hybrid credit/agency model is lagging the recovery playing out at some peers. The bull case rests on a projected 9.9% ROE and 12% growth in conventional origination volume. The bear case centres on book value erosion and a shrinking servicing UPB — two metrics that will be front and centre when management reports on August 4.
The last two earnings prints produced a one-day move of -0.8% and -8.9% respectively, with five-day follow-through of -0.9% and -13.6%. The question for the week ahead is whether the options market's reduced defensiveness reflects genuine confidence in the quarter, or simply position cleanup after a month of sustained selling — and whether shorts who covered this week return after the number drops.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open PMT on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
