Nu Holdings Slips After Weak Print, Enters Second Report With Street Still Split

Nu Holdings heads into its August 13 earnings report having already disappointed once this cycle — and the positioning data suggests traders are only marginally more defensive than they were before that miss.

The stock dropped roughly 4.4% on the day of its August 6 print, extending a week that saw shares fall 3.4% to close at $13.84. That follows a near-identical pattern from May, when the stock fell 4.9% on earnings day before recovering about 2.7% over the following five sessions. Options traders appear to be pricing in a similar dynamic: the put/call ratio of 0.56 is only a hair above its 20-day average of 0.54, with a z-score of just 0.5. That is not defensive positioning — it sits close to the middle of its 52-week range. The borrow market reinforces that calm. Availability runs at roughly 2,074%, meaning there are more than twenty shares available to lend for every one already borrowed. Cost to borrow has doubled over the past week to 0.60%, but in absolute terms that remains very low. Short interest has drifted down about 5% over the past month to 3.9% of the float, unwinding the spike that peaked in mid-July near 160 million shares. Overall, positioning looks alert but not crowded.

The analyst community is where the real tension sits. The clearest recent move came from JP Morgan, which raised its target to $20 in early July — a vote of confidence that stands in direct contrast to the wave of downgrades that swept through May and June, when Citigroup, Susquehanna, and BofA Securities all cut ratings while slashing targets to the $10–$13 range. The mean analyst target of roughly $18 implies about 30% upside from current levels, but that figure masks the polarisation: bulls point to NU's continued customer growth across Latin America and a forward earnings yield that has held up despite the recent stock weakness, while bears argue the June-quarter miss showed that credit quality and operating costs in Brazil are harder to manage than the growth narrative suggests. EPS momentum scores are robust — ranking in the 82nd and 87th percentiles over 30 and 90 days respectively — yet the EPS surprise factor ranks in only the 17th percentile, a sign that estimates have been running ahead of delivery. The stock trades at roughly 13.5x earnings and 3.8x book, neither obviously cheap nor stretched given the growth profile, but enough to leave little room for another shortfall.

The August 13 print will test whether NU can demonstrate that the August 6 disappointment was an anomaly in an otherwise intact growth story — or whether the bears who downgraded in May and June were simply early.