Alibaba reported on September 22 and the pre-earnings call euphoria has given way to a more sober read: the stock is up just 0.5% on the day and 6.4% on the week, but the options market has unwound its most aggressive bullish tilt of the year — and borrowing costs are quietly climbing.
The sharpest change from last week's setup is in options sentiment. Before earnings, the put/call ratio had collapsed to 0.497, a full 2.2 standard deviations below its 20-day average and the lowest reading in 52 weeks. Call buyers were in control. That positioning has partially normalised: the PCR is now 0.543, roughly 1.4 standard deviations below its 20-day mean of 0.574. The call skew persists, but it is less extreme. Traders leaned bullish into the print and got a modest rather than explosive reaction — the stock added 0.5% on the day. The most aggressive positioning has been trimmed, leaving a setup that is mildly constructive rather than stretched.
The lending market has tightened meaningfully since last week's note. Borrow availability has dropped to 121% from 154% a week ago — a 21.5% tightening in seven days. That still places availability in the "tight but not extreme" range, but the direction matters. Simultaneously, cost to borrow has jumped 46% on the week to 0.70%, its highest level in the 30-day window. Short interest has also nudged up 1% on the week to approximately 42.3 million shares, reversing a multi-week drift lower. None of these individually are alarming, but together they suggest renewed demand to borrow BABA shares post-earnings — the market is not universally convinced the reaction is done.
The Street is broadly constructive but with acknowledged tensions. JP Morgan and Barclays both raised targets to $210 and $200 respectively in late August, maintaining Overweight ratings. Susquehanna followed, lifting to $190. Baird was the outlier, trimming slightly to $160 while keeping Outperform. The bull case centres on cloud and e-commerce momentum — revenue grew 5% year-on-year in the latest quarter (15% excluding disposed assets), and daily active users on Taobao rose 20% following the instant commerce integration. The bear case is harder to dismiss: China Ecommerce EBITA margins have been cut to 23% for the second half of this fiscal year, EBITDA missed consensus by RMB 2 billion, and free cash flow turned negative owing to quick commerce investment and cloud infrastructure spend. On valuation, the stock trades at 13.7x trailing earnings and 8.9x EV/EBITDA — both multiples have compressed slightly over the past week as the price moved up while earnings estimates stayed flat. That compression is modest, but it narrows the margin of safety relative to the target prices above.
The earnings history adds important context. The August 20 print — one cycle earlier — sent the stock down 7.4% on the day and nearly 10% over the following five days. That reaction, on what appeared to be a credible revenue beat, underlines how sensitive BABA remains to margin disappointment. The September 22 result produced a far calmer response, which may itself be informative: either the market had already absorbed the margin concerns, or the reaction is still unfolding. With the next earnings event not until November 19, the tape has two months to digest where Alibaba's margins are actually heading.
The week ahead will be defined by whether the post-earnings borrow tightening stabilises or continues — and whether the cost-to-borrow move above 0.70% holds, which would mark its clearest break above the range that has contained it for most of the past three months.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open BABA on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
