Energy Transfer LP exits a strong week with an awkward tension at its core: the stock is up 5% in five sessions and trading at its best level in months, yet the cost to borrow shares has almost doubled over the same period — a sharp divergence that puts the lending market squarely in focus.
The borrow story is the standout this week. Cost to borrow has surged nearly 90% over the past five sessions, climbing from roughly 3.4% to 6.5% APR. That is the highest rate in over a month and marks a striking reversal from the low of 1.2% seen in late April, when borrow was near its cheapest point of the trailing period. The driver is not a flood of new short sellers — short interest remains negligible at just 0.84% of the free float, essentially unchanged on the week. Instead, the spike reflects a technical tightening in the lending pool. Availability has dropped sharply, a move that is more likely the result of dealer positioning and settlement flows around the Q1 earnings release on May 5 than a structural shift in bearish conviction. The ORTEX short score, at 30.2, has ticked up modestly over the past two sessions but remains well below any level that would flag meaningful short pressure.
Options positioning reinforces that picture. Calls are overwhelmingly dominant: the put/call ratio is running at 0.16, slightly below its 20-day average of 0.17 and near the 52-week low of 0.14. Call buyers have been firmly in control for several weeks. That is broadly consistent with the price action — up 7.7% over the past month — and signals that derivatives traders are not hedging heavily into the Q1 print. The lack of put demand stands in contrast to the borrow tightening, which might ordinarily suggest defensive positioning. Here, the two signals diverge: the options market looks comfortably bullish while the lending market is quietly stressed.
On the Street, the directional lean is constructive. The mean analyst price target is $22.69, roughly 11% above Tuesday's close of $20.39. Most recently, Stifel raised its target from $23 to $25 on May 6, keeping a Buy rating — a timely lift that arrived alongside the earnings release. Earlier in the year, Wells Fargo also raised its target to $25 (Overweight), while Truist initiated with a Buy at $23 in March. Morgan Stanley is the notable outlier, sitting at Equal-Weight with a $21 target — essentially flat to the current price. The EV/EBITDA multiple has drifted lower over the past month to 8.6x, compressing modestly as the enterprise value has risen. The 12-month forward dividend yield is 6.78%, and Energy Transfer's dividend score ranks in the 94th percentile of the universe — a reminder that income investors are a core constituency here, not a footnote. Forward EPS growth ranks in the 81st percentile on a year-over-year basis, giving the bull case some fundamental backing beyond the yield.
The ownership backdrop is notable for one name. Founder and Executive Chairman Kelcy Warren holds over 305 million units — nearly 9% of outstanding shares — and added 3 million units in two tranches during August and November 2025 at prices between $16.81 and $17.36. That buying, now well over 20% below the current price, reflects a conviction at much lower levels. No insider activity has been reported since December 2025, when several senior executives — including both Co-CEOs — sold modest holdings at $16.60. Those sales look opportunistic at a price that is now 23% below current levels, reducing their signalling value considerably.
The next scheduled earnings call lands August 5. Between now and then, the most informative data points to track are whether the cost to borrow normalises as settlement flows clear, and whether the call-heavy options structure holds — or begins to attract put interest — as the stock tests higher ground near the analyst consensus target zone.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open ET on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
