TOST enters September with a fresh analyst downgrade, a stock down 8.7% on the week, and options traders leaning bullish — a trio of signals that don't quite agree with each other.
The downgrade came overnight. BNP Paribas cut Toast to Neutral from Outperform and trimmed its target to $35 from $38 — placing the new target within a whisker of where the stock actually trades at $33.59. The move reflects a view that the easy re-rating has happened. It follows a post-earnings wave of upgrades from early August, when a Q2 beat prompted Bernstein, UBS, Citi, Truist, and Oppenheimer to all lift targets — most into the high $30s to mid-$40s range. RBC went further, raising its target to $44 this week even as it held a Sector Perform rating. The broader consensus remains Hold, with a mean target near $38.90 — about 16% above current levels — suggesting the Street still sees value even after the BNP retreat. Bears worry that Toast's valuation, at a P/E of ~21.8x and EV/EBITDA of ~19x, leaves little room for error given the company's ongoing investment cycle.
Options positioning tells a markedly more constructive story. The put/call ratio has fallen to 0.57, more than two standard deviations below its 20-day average of 0.63. That's the lowest call-skew reading of the past year — and it's arrived precisely as the stock has sold off. Call buyers aren't fleeing the dip; they're leaning into it. Paired with a short score of 47.6 that ranks in the bottom quarter of the universe (24th percentile), the options signal looks like genuine conviction rather than a reflexive hedge unwind.
Short interest reinforces the cautious-but-not-crowded read. Bears have actually been covering, not adding. SI has dropped roughly 23% over the past month to 6.1% of free float, down from above 9.5% in late July. The week-on-week decline of 5.2% continues a trend that began immediately after the August earnings beat. Borrow conditions remain loose — availability of ~458% means there are more than four shares available to lend for every one currently borrowed — and cost-to-borrow at 0.58% is negligible despite ticking up 19% on the week. Shorts exiting rather than pressing distinguishes this setup from a high-conviction bearish trade.
The institutional register adds a notable footnote. BlackRock's latest Schedule 13G filing — dated July 30 — disclosed a 9.3% stake, up from 4.98% at its previous filing. That's a near-doubling of the position. The activist register carries no 13D filers, and all 13G holders are disclosed as passive; as always, these stakes are as-last-disclosed and holders dropping below 5% may exit without filing again. Insider activity from the recent 90-day window is limited to the CRO's planned stock-sales and option exercises under a 10b5-1 programme — mechanistic compensation monetisation rather than a directional signal.
The next earnings date is November 6. Toast's most recent print produced a 6.1% one-day gain and held most of that move over five sessions. The question heading into Q4 is whether BNP's view — that the re-rating story has played out — gains more followers among a sell-side cohort that, for now, remains predominantly constructive above current prices.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open TOST on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
