C3.ai has just printed its fiscal Q1 results, and the post-earnings landscape confirms the bears' thesis rather than denting it — short interest barely budged, options traders who positioned for a pop saw the stock fall 4.4% on the day, and the Street remains overwhelmingly cautious.
The positioning story is largely unchanged from the pre-earnings note, but the direction of travel matters. Short interest dipped fractionally on September 1 to 35.0% of the free float — down less than 1% on the day — after a week that added roughly 2.5% to the short position. Bears built through August and did not rush to cover after the print. The borrow market remains permissive: availability has actually loosened to 230% from around 203% a week ago, meaning shares to lend now comfortably outnumber those already borrowed at a ratio of more than two-to-one. Cost to borrow is just 0.52%, down 7% on the week. There is no squeeze pressure — shorts can add, hold, or exit without friction. What changed in options is more striking: the put/call ratio collapsed to 0.44 heading into earnings, nearly two standard deviations below its 20-day average of 0.50. That call-heavy positioning reflected speculative upside bets. With the stock down 4.4% on results day, those calls expired or are now deeply underwater, and the setup reverts to one where the bears look vindicated for this cycle.
The Street's read on AI has been consistently negative, and the most recent analyst action did nothing to change that. DA Davidson reiterated its Underperform rating and $7.00 target on September 1 — the day results dropped — holding a view it has maintained without revision for months. The broader analyst consensus reflects a similar picture: Morgan Stanley carries an Underweight with a $7.00 target, and the mean price target across the panel is $8.82, against a current price of $10.34. That implies roughly 15% downside to consensus, making AI one of the rare names where the stock is trading above where most analysts think it should be. Wedbush remains the outlier bull, reiterating Outperform with a $15 target — a view premised on federal AI demand growth, where C3.ai has genuinely delivered, with government bookings reportedly up 139% year-on-year. The divide between the Wedbush bull case and the Morgan Stanley / DA Davidson bear case is as wide as it has been all year. The ORTEX short score of 71.2 ranks in the 4th percentile of the universe on that measure — deeply bearish positioning by historical standards.
The valuation picture does little to support the bulls. The company generates negative earnings — the trailing P/E is -18.2 and EV/EBITDA is -10.6, both deepening in negative territory over the past 30 days as the stock recovered from July lows even as fundamentals eroded. The price-to-book of 3.3x is the cleanest positive multiple available, and it has expanded 0.5 turns over the past month. EPS momentum ranks in just the 7th percentile over 90 days, though the company has a notable EPS surprise track record, ranking in the 88th percentile — suggesting it has a habit of beating low expectations even when the absolute numbers are ugly. The most recent earnings history is thin but pointed: the June print produced a 5.4% one-day decline and a 3.4% five-day decline, a pattern that rhymes with where the stock sits now.
On the ownership side, Thomas Siebel — founder, executive chairman, and still the second-largest reported holder at roughly 7.6% of shares — sold 139,500 shares on August 3 at $9.61 for just over $1.3 million. That sale was not conducted under a 10b5-1 plan, which makes it a discretionary trade rather than a pre-scheduled one. The net insider position over the past 90 days is negative $1.34 million. Siebel's reported 13G/A stake has also declined from 17.2% to 15.3% since last year's filing. BlackRock is the largest institutional holder at 9.2% of shares, though its most recent 13G/A reflected a trim from 8.0% to 6.8%. Peers in the enterprise software space had a mixed week: NOW fell 3.4% on the day but gained 12.5% on the week, while PLTR dropped 3.5% on the day against a 4.2% weekly gain — suggesting the sector-wide Tuesday selloff hit broadly, and AI's single-day drop cannot be read in isolation from macro pressure.
The next scheduled catalyst is the fiscal Q2 earnings call on October 26. Between now and then, the key question is whether short sellers — who built aggressively through August at no squeeze cost — continue adding into a stock that remains above the Street's mean target, or whether the post-earnings dip brings in fresh long-side buyers willing to bet against the consensus.
See the live data behind this article on ORTEX.
Open AI on ORTEX →ORTEX Market Intelligence content is generated by AI from a snapshot of ORTEX's proprietary data. Content is informational only and does not constitute investment advice.
