HTZ: Borrow Cost Spikes as Short Score Climbs to New High

Hertz Global Holdings enters October with its short score at a fresh high and borrowing costs jumping sharply, even as the stock posts a rare weekly gain. The lending market remains structurally closed. Availability has been at zero for every session tracked over the past six weeks, meaning every share in the lending pool is already lent out. That has been the persistent backdrop since mid-July and has not changed. What has changed is the cost of maintaining those positions. Cost to borrow closed the week at 9.20%, up 51% from where it stood seven days earlier. The move is notable: it brings borrowing costs back close to levels last seen in late August, when the rate briefly touched the low-to-mid 9% range before retreating. At the same time, the ORTEX short score climbed to 76.2 on October 2, up from 73.0 a week earlier. That is the highest reading in the series shown here, and the acceleration over the final two sessions of the week was the sharpest in the trailing ten days. Short interest edged marginally lower on the week, down 0.6% to 119.7 million shares, but that follows a 14.5% build over the prior month. The position still equates to 38.4% of the free float, one of the most extreme short concentrations in the US market. The options market leans slightly defensive but without conviction. The put/call ratio is running at 1.04, modestly above its 20-day average of 0.96, with a z-score of 0.88. That points to mild incremental put demand rather than any sharp rotation toward downside hedges. The 52-week range for the PCR is wide, from 0.66 to 2.31, so the current reading is far from extreme. Options traders are cautious but not alarmed, a different tone from the short-seller community. The Street's view has darkened steadily. Morgan Stanley cut its target to $3.00 from $3.50 in mid-September while holding an Equal-Weight rating. Earlier reductions from Goldman Sachs (target to $2.00, Sell), Barclays (target to $1.00, Underweight) and Susquehanna (target to $2.50 from $5.50, Neutral) between late July and mid-August painted a consistent picture of analysts ratcheting down expectations with no upgrade to offset. The mean price target across the group is $2.22. At the current price of $1.76, that implies roughly 26% to the consensus, but Barclays' $1.00 target sits below where the stock trades today. The EV/EBITDA multiple has compressed to 39.3x, down from around 42x thirty days ago, as the enterprise value drifts lower with the share price. The ORTEX factor score for short score rank is at the 5th percentile, meaning almost every other stock in the universe scores less bearish on this measure. Ownership tells a tale of extreme concentration. Knighthead Capital, the activist 13D filer operating through CK Amarillo LP, holds 181.5 million shares, representing 50.9% of the company as last disclosed in August. The 13D classification means the filer has declared an active intent, not a passive stake. As a practical matter, with Knighthead holding more than half the company and the borrow market entirely closed, the shares available to short are structurally limited to what sits outside that anchor position. Jane Street filed a fresh 13G in July disclosing a 5.0% passive stake, while Pershing Square held 4.2% as of June 30 with a marginal trim. BlackRock added 1.9 million shares through September, taking its position to 5.7%. The activist disclosure caveat applies: stakes reflect the 5% threshold filing trigger, and positions below that level can exit without further notice. Earnings are scheduled for November 6, thirty-two days away. The last print on August 6 produced a one-day move of 45.5% and a five-day move of 50.3%, which frames the event risk plainly. Whether the cost-to-borrow spike this week reflects short sellers bracing for that event, covering in front of it, or simply a tighter pool as borrowable supply shrinks further is the question worth watching into the coming sessions.

How this article was generated